How The Two Lenders Have Fared Financially

Banks are generally known as the spine of an financial system  as a result of they preserve enough liquidity by circulating cash within the financial system. Banks present individuals a platform to park their surplus money in addition to borrow after they fall quick. According to the RBI, the cumulative credit score of Indian banks stood at Rs 110.46 lakh crore on the finish of September 2021.However, India continues to be an underpenetrated market when it comes to banking providers primarily attributable to low degree of economic literacy within the nation. As a consequence, the overall credit score excellent is simply 15% of the overall worth of all items and providers produced within the nation.Private sector banks and public sector banks (PSBs) collectively make up for the Indian banking trade. For the final twenty years, non-public banks have outperformed PSBs, largely attributable to higher administration. In this text, we examine India's “too big to fail banking behemoths” HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank to see how they stack up in opposition to one another.Banks run on a quite simple enterprise mannequin. To perceive the enterprise mannequin, you'll want to first perceive the operational dynamics of a financial institution. The primary operational premise of a financial institution contains two main operations - accepting deposits and lending to debtors. Deposits Deposits are the first supply of funds for a financial institution with out which it can not function. This is as a result of the financial institution makes use of the cash it receives from deposits to lend to debtors. There are various kinds of deposits that contribute to the general deposit base of a financial institution. These embrace deposits from present accounts and financial savings accounts (CASA), time deposits (certificates of deposits), mounted deposits, and many others. Given its significance, let us take a look at the deposit base of HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank and the way it has grown during the last 5 years. Clearly, HDFC Bank has a better deposit base than ICICI Bank. Also, the previous has been rising its deposit base at a quicker charge than the latter. HDFC Bank's deposit base has grown at double digit CAGR of 15.7% during the last 5 years. This is in comparison with ICICI Bank's common development of 13.4% throughout the identical interval. Advances Now, let's check out the opposite facet of the equation which is worried with loans. Banks use their deposits to disburse loans or advances as they name it in banking parlance. The development of advances ought to sustain with the expansion of a financial institution's deposits. Following desk compares advances of HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank.  Even right here, HDFC Bank's advances have grown quicker than ICICI Bank's . For the final 5 years, HDFC Bank's advances have grown at a CAGR of 15.1% in comparison with ICICI Bank's 9% CAGR throughout the identical interval. For the 12 months ended March 2021, HDFC Bank's advances had been 88.9% of its whole deposits whereas this determine was 82.5% for ICICI Bank. Clearly, HDFC Bank is more environment friendly than ICICI Bank when it comes to utilising its deposit base. Net Interest Income (NII)Now, coming to how a financial institution makes earnings, you'll want to know its main sources of income and prices it incurs. Let's discuss prices first. The banking trade is extraordinarily aggressive. A financial institution needs you to park your cash with it and never with its friends. In a bid to accumulate more deposits, a financial institution gives you incentives in your deposits. This incentive known as curiosity which is calculated as a share of your deposits. Interest paid to depositors is a serious price incurred by a financial institution and constitutes a big chunk of its whole bills. On the opposite hand, a financial institution prices an curiosity on loans supplied. Interest earned by loans is a serious income for a financial institution and constitutes a big chunk of its whole income. The curiosity charged to debtors is all the time increased than the curiosity supplied to depositors. The distinction between the curiosity earned and curiosity paid is the financial institution's gross earnings. This differential is also referred to as web curiosity earnings (NII). The following desk exhibits how HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank stack up in opposition to one another on these metrics.

HDFC Bank's NII has grown at a CAGR of 14.5% during the last years whereas ICICI Bank's NII has grown at a CAGR of 12.2% throughout the identical interval. Net Interest MarginNet curiosity margin (NIM) is principally web curiosity earnings divided by the overall quantity of mortgage disbursed by a financial institution. It is without doubt one of the measures of a financial institution's profitability. Therefore, increased the NIM the higher it's for banks. The following desk exhibits web curiosity margin of HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank.

HDFC Bank's increased curiosity earnings has translated into increased NIM for the financial institution. HDFC Bank's web curiosity earnings has been fairly secure over years and averages at 4.6%. This is in comparison with ICICI Bank's common of three.2%. Which financial institution scores effectively on this essential metric?The largest worry of any financial institution is its debtors defaulting on their fee obligations. A borrower could achieve this willfully or he/she could also be unable to meet fee obligations attributable to unexpected circumstances. An instance of willful delinquency could be that of the flamboyant Vijay Mallya who took a large mortgage of Rs 700 crore from a consortium of banks led by State Bank of India (SBI) to fund the operations of now defunct airline Kingfisher. An instance of the latter could be of Covid-19 pandemic which severely affected the enterprise panorama. Many individuals misplaced their jobs which dented their monetary place which in flip led to their incapability to pay their loans. In any case, if the fee is overdue for a interval of greater than 90 days, then the mortgage turns into a non-performing belongings (NPA). as a result of the financial institution is not incomes any curiosity from the respective mortgage. NPAs past a sure restrict may drain the fortune of a financial institution resulting in its chapter. To keep away from such a scenario, it's essential for a financial institution to verify the creditworthiness of a person or entity to whom the mortgage is being supplied. The efficiency of HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank have been exemplary on this area. The following desk exhibits NPAs reported by HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank. It is expressed as a share of a financial institution's whole advances. 

As may be seen from the desk, HDFC Bank has constantly reported decrease NPAs. The 5 12 months common of HDFC Bank's NPAs is roughly 0.4% which is the bottom within the trade. It implies that if HDFC Bank disburses a complete mortgage of Rs 100 then Rs 0.4 does not come again to the financial institution. It ought to come as no shock that HDFC Bank holds the excellence of reporting greater than 20% YoY revenue development each quarter for over 40 quarters. All this whereas, its web NPAs have by no means crossed 0.5% of loans!The 5 12 months common of ICICI Bank's NPAs is 3.16% which is nowhere close to HDFC Bank. Although the common appears excessive, it is very important observe that ICICI Bank's NPAs have come down drastically ever because the prime degree administration was modified in 2017 and Mr Sandeep Bakshi was instated because the CEO of the financial institution. Net ProfitClosely related to NPAs are provisions. Whenever a financial institution experiences an NPA it has to maintain apart a portion of its curiosity earnings to supply for the loss incurred as a result of respective NPA. Provisions are a serious expenditure for banks and impression their web earnings considerably. This may be seen within the case of HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank. The following desk compares the web earnings of HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank. 

HDFC Bank's web earnings have grown at a CAGR of 15.9% during the last 5 years. This is in comparison with ICICI Bank's web revenue development of 12.5%. ICICI Bank's web revenue development is gradual as in comparison with HDFC Bank primarily attributable to excessive provisions being reported by the financial institution.Also, HDFC Bank has reported comparatively increased and secure margins as in comparison with ICICI Bank. The following desk exhibits the web revenue margins of HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank.

Dividend PayoutInvestors are likely to put money into firms that pay dividends to their shareholders.Dividend is corporate's accrued earnings distributed equally amongst shareholders. An organization could pay a dividend when it does not have any fast bills to pay for.The following desk exhibits the dividend paid by HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank to their shareholders during the last 5 years.

HDFC Bank has paid a mean of Rs 5.7 to every shareholder during the last 5 years. This is in comparison with ICICI Bank's common of Rs 1.4 throughout the identical interval.Another dividend metric that traders take a look at earlier than investing in any firm is dividend payout ratio. Dividend payout ratio determines how a lot dividend an organization is paying from its earnings. The five-year common dividend payout ratio of HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank is 12.4% and 9.9%, respectively.Banking retailersPhysical branches are nonetheless a most popular mode of accessing primary banking providers particularly in rural areas. Therefore, bodily branches maintain significance for a financial institution's development. To guarantee final mile supply of primary banking providers, Indian banks serve its clients by third occasion companions who're also referred to as enterprise correspondents (BCs) particularly in areas the place it isn't possible for banks to function a full-fledged bodily department. As of March 2021, HDFC Bank had a complete of 21,364 banking retailers  internationally. ICICI Bank had a complete of 9,266 banking retailers  unfold throughout India as of March 2021. Of the overall, 5,266 are bodily branches and 51% of the overall bodily branches are current in rural areas. The remaining banking retailers are BCs. Investments and acquisitionsApart from bodily banking retailers, Indian banks have been specializing in creating digital channels to ship seamless banking expertise to clients and cut back their prices. Banks have been investing and collaborating with fintech firms to leverage their technological experience and increase their attain. HDFC Bank entered right into a strategic partnership with Paytm to leverage Paytm's digital platform and increase its attain in rural markets the place Paytm enjoys good rapport with small retailers. This partnership will assist the financial institution to burgeon its retail mortgage e book. HDFC Bank has additionally invested in Bengaluru primarily based wealth administration tech platform Smallcase. Meanwhile, ICICI Bank has partnered with fintech platform Niyo to supply pay as you go playing cards to MSME employees with the target to rope them beneath the banking ecosystem. The financial institution has launched “iMobile Pay” to seize a big market share within the UPI fee market which is dominated by fintech firms like Phonepe and Google Pay. Return and Valuation ratiosWhile evaluating banks, analysts often use three ratios to search out out which is undervalued. These three ratios are return on fairness (ROE), return on belongings (ROA), and worth to e book worth (P/BV). Return on fairness (ROE) tells an investor how a lot revenue an organization generates on shareholders capital. It is expressed when it comes to share. Return on belongings (ROA) tells an investor how a lot revenue an organization generates on whole belongings the corporate owns. Important level to notice is loans are belongings for banks and ROA is calculated as a ratio of web earnings to its whole performing (producing curiosity earnings) belongings. For banks, ROA of 1% is a benchmark and something past that's thought of wonderful. Price to e book worth (P/BV) signifies the value an investor is keen to pay for every rupee of an organization's e book worth.

HDFC Bank outperforms ICICI Bank when it comes to ROE and ROA. HDFC Bank trades at a better P/BV than ICICI Bank primarily as a result of the market is giving increased worth to HDFC Bank's constant efficiency. Clearly, HDFC Bank is a little bit overvalued right here however for the suitable causes. Impact of Covid-19When the lockdown was introduced to curb the unfold of the virus, banking shares plunged probably the most. Stock costs fell within the anticipation that NPAs would shoot up considerably. However, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), was fast to announce a slew of measures which helped the debtors and the banks to face the brunt of the pandemic. To begin with, the RBI introduced a six month moratorium on mortgage funds. This measure helped banks report decrease than anticipated NPAs and consequently stem their losses. Also, the RBI executed long run repo operations in order that the banks can borrow from the RBI at a minimal charge of 4% and lend it ahead to these in want. This measure ensured that enough liquidity was maintained within the financial system and the financial engine is not hindered attributable to non-availability of required capital. For the primary two quarters of the monetary 12 months 2021, though the banks reported decrease NPA figures, additionally they reported flat or unfavorable income and revenue development. However, demand revived within the third and the fourth quarter as restrictions had been eased and pageant season dawned upon the nation. Home loans had been the most important demand driver within the retail class attributable to decrease rate of interest regime and softening actual property costs. In the wholesale class, banks financed the elevated working capital necessities attributable to excessive enter price and freight price. Thanks to this revived demand, Indian banks closed the 12 months on a wholesome observe.Future prospectsA big a part of India continues to be credit score averse. Lots of people in India see loans and credit score in a foul mild. As a consequence, India lags behind developed nations when it comes to credit score. India's whole excellent loans to gross home product (GDP) is simply 15% in comparison with 80-100% in its western counterparts. So India has received lots to cowl and there's a lot of headroom for development for Indian banks. Let's take a look at a number of the prospects of how India could obtain increased credit score development and monetary inclusion. To begin with, as firms undertake China plus one technique, they see India as an apparent various. The Indian authorities too is this chance to make India as the largest manufacturing hub on the earth. Small and medium enterprises (SME) would play a vital position in making India a producing hub. Hence, SME financing could possibly be a terrific alternative for banks to develop their mortgage e book.Also, it's anticipated that folks at present working within the agriculture sector would shift to the manufacturing sector as soon as the sector begins rising. Therefore, rural markets would current a brand new wave of development for banks to experience on. However, digital, and monetary literacy stays an enormous problem. Banks need to sort out this problem in the event that they want to leverage the untapped potential of the agricultural market. Last however not least, due diligence stays a key for any financial institution's success. Any financial institution which follows a top quality due diligence framework and retains a verify on its dangerous loans will emerge as a frontrunner. HDFC Bank is an ideal instance of this. To sum up, HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank being the highest gamers within the trade are poised to develop as the general trade grows. Equitymaster's viewWe reached out to Tanushree Banerjee, Co-head of Research at Equitymaster for her view on each banks. Here's what she needed to say...While the regulatory situation for fintech's continues to be evolving, there isn't a doubt that the sector gives large alternative. Both, the incumbents i.e. the prevailing tech focussed banks like HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank in addition to the brand new age gamers with area of interest modern fintech choices, have room for development.Which is healthier? If we examine the 2 banks on credit score development then each banks are rising their mortgage e book nearly at an equal charge throughout the curiosity cycle.However, if we examine them on the credit score high quality, HDFC Bank is way forward than ICICI Bank. HDFC Bank has reported constantly decrease and secure NPAs throughout the curiosity cycle whereas ICICI Bank's credit score high quality has fluctuated lots and is comparatively unstable. On the web curiosity margin entrance too, HDFC Bank scores higher than ICICI financial institution. However, ever because the administration of ICICI Bank was overhauled with Sanjay Bakshi taking cost, there was a drastic enchancment within the financial institution's efficiency. It's inching nearer in the direction of HDFC Bank when it comes to monetary efficiency. This is one thing that must be famous. Though this text might need made issues simpler for you, we strongly suggest you to verify the basics and valuations of each these firms by yourself.Disclaimer: This article is for data functions solely. It will not be a inventory advice and shouldn't be handled as such.(This article is syndicated from Equitymaster.com)

(This story has not been edited by NDTV employees and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)